전체 글45 반박의 기술 12가지 - 3탄 오늘은 이전에 소개해드렸던 반박의 기술 4가지를 더 살펴보도록 하겠습니다. 그럼, 달려보시져 - 1. Not True 2. Wrong in principle 3. Generalization 4. Insignificant 5. Irrelevant 6. Problem + Solution mismatch 7. Contradiction 8. Assumption 9. Cause more harm (+Slippery Slope) 10. Not mutually exclusive 11. Logically inconsistent 12. Not their role (+ Even if) 9. Cause more harm (+Slippery Slope) 이 반박은 상대측이 주로 어떤 정책이나 문제에 대한 해결책으로 새로운 제.. 2020. 5. 22. THW Revoke citizenship of individuals who participate in terrorism overseas. (GOVERNMENT) Context The recent outbreak of the IS (Islamic State) has brought international attention to fighting terrorism. The war on terrorism itself is not a new concept. International communities have been trying to eradicate the act of terror, particularly after the 9.11 attack in the United States. Yet, the problem is, we are not winning this war so far. As a matter of fact, the recent i.. 2019. 6. 7. THW amend the constitution to allow the presidents to re-run for office [Proposition] Democratic nations such as Korea, Philippines, Mexico and 10 other nations, have limited presidents to re-run for office. Such system does not guarantee democratic principles and should amend its constitutions to get rid of the limitations. Majority of nations, such as the United States, allow presidents to run for office more than once. We also support such approach, but in additi.. 2019. 6. 6. THW ban "Il-Gan Best" [Proposition] Clarification: We are not banning "Il-Gan Best" simply because they sometimes post inappropriate things. We propose to ban "Il-Gan Best" since it’s undemocratic, and poses serious harm to our society. Moreover, we are willing to ban another interment websites that have identical characteristics and harms to our society. Constructive Case 1: What is "Il-Gan Best" and what kind of ha.. 2019. 6. 5. Should Physical Education remain compulsory? Proposition Problem Identification: 1. Society tend to under appreciate the importance of Physical Education 2. Many children are becoming seriously obese from a young age Definition: Compulsory Physical Education means that all schools must fulfill minimum amount of physical education class. A1) Characteristics of P.E and the Need to make it Compulsory 1. What is unique about P.E classes in sch.. 2019. 6. 4. THW not tax the poor PROPOSITION Poverty is an urgent problem even though most people don’t feel it. While some people celebrate the invention of advanced technology and scientific breakthrough, others struggle everyday due to food shortage and extremely low standard of living. We believe that such extreme poverty infringes the basic rights of human. Therefore, eradication of poverty should be one of the priority of.. 2019. 6. 1. 본 의회는 디자이너 베이비의 활용을 허용할 것이다. 찬성 반대 논거 1. 한 사람의 인생을 바꾼다. 현재 디자이너 베이비는 희귀 혈액 질환이나 암 등 불치병을 앓고 있는 자녀를 치료하기 위한 목적을 가진 기술입니다. 희귀 혈액질환이나 암 등을 앓고 있는 자녀를 치료하는 데 이용할 줄기세포를 얻기 위해 시험관 수정기술을 통해 질환 자녀의 세포조직과 완전히 일치하는 특정 배아를 가려내 이 가운데 질병 유전자가 없는 정상적인 배아를 골라 탄생시킨 아기를 말합니다. 그 예를 들자면 최초의 디자이너 베이비는 2000년 8월 29일 미국에서 탄생했습니다. 유전질환을 가진 6살 여자아이를 치료한다는 목적을 가지고 이 기술이 사용되었고, 아이는 골 수이식 3주일 만에 정상적인 생활을 할 수 있었습니다. 유전질환으로 평생토록 고통받아야만 했던 아이가 디자이너 베이비를 통.. 2019. 5. 31. THW prefer a short and successful life over a mundane healthy life PROPOSITION Prime Minister Mr.Speaker, ladies and gentlemen, members of the house - When Viktor Frankl, a Jewish psychologist, was detained inside Auschwitz during the Holocaust, he observed his fellow prisoners to find out what kind of people survived until the end. His observations are shocking. Because it wasn’t the strongest people who had survived until the end, it wasn’t the smartest peopl.. 2019. 5. 30. THW ban parking lots in megacities Proposition -PM Introduction: Side government believes that private vehicle use unquestionably produces vast pollution in megacities. Motor vehicles are the single largest contributor to air pollution emissions. We believe this not only lowers the efficiency of commuting but also lowers the quality of life of residence in the megacities. To minimize such harms, we believe government must reduce .. 2019. 5. 29. 반박의 기술 12가지 - 2탄 오늘은 지난번에 이어서 반박의 기술 4가지를 더 살펴보도록 하겠습니다. 그럼, 달려보시져 - 1. Not True 2. Wrong in principle 3. Generalization 4. Insignificant 5. Irrelevant 6. Problem + Solution mismatch 7. Contradiction 8. Assumption 9. Cause more harm (+Slippery Slope) 10. Not mutually exclusive 11. Logically inconsistent 12. Not their role (+ Even if) 5. Irrelevant (상관이 없다) 이 반박은 상대방의 주장 중 일부, 또는 전부가 토론 주제와 상관이 없는 경우에 그것을 집어낼 때 사.. 2019. 5. 28. 이전 1 2 3 4 5 다음 반응형